Anger over train overcrowding as fares set to increase 3.4% through 2018

Rail fares are rising again in 2018, at an average rate of 3.4%. This is the largest price hike in years, and it came into effect on January 2. Though some rail companies are staggering the price rise, commuters are already starting to feel the impact as ticket prices go up. However, commuters are speaking out about the unsatisfactory standards private rail companies demonstrate.

Labour members campaigning at Scarborough station against the 2018 rise in rail fares

Labour members campaigning at Scarborough station against the 2018 rise in rail fares


Overcrowded trains, delays and high ticket prices are making travel a misery for many people. The constituencies of Scarborough and Whitby are badly affected by these problems with the trains, because of our distance from major towns and cities and our limited road network. Many residents rely on the railways for work or for personal travel, despite the high costs and poor service, while others have been priced out of using the trains entirely.

Many trains leaving Scarborough fail to provide enough carriages, or overbook seats, leading to crowding of carriages. It is common for passengers to pay to reserve seats, but be unable to use them because the train is so full. Despite having paid a high price for a ticket, there is no guarantee you will have a comfortable journey – or get to your destination on time. Delays are very common, while many trains and the stations they serve are in need of renovation. Though private companies often make a significant profit from our railways, they are offering an increasingly subpar service to their customers.

“The service has not improved over the years, and in fact has got worse,” notes Labour Councillor Eric Broadbent. “I travelled from Scarborough to Leeds last Saturday and at Scarborough Station passengers waiting to board were all herded on to the front three carriages as the doors would not unlock on the rear three carriages. You can imagine the crush that happened all the way to Leeds, and the arguments that ensued.”

The Labour Party’s national policy is to nationalise the railways again, bringing control of the rail network back into public ownership and allowing us to put the profits of the rail service back into its infrastructure. After costs, any surplus profits would be put back into the treasury to be spent on our public services. The Scarborough and Whitby CLP wholeheartedly backs this policy, and believes our town could benefit greatly from a renationalised rail network that better serves local residents, ends the overcrowding, and makes train travel affordable again.

It is now cheaper to drive than to take the train, and the hikes to rail prices will make that price gap wider. This is bad news for our local environment, with more cars on the road than ever before – contributing to higher pollution levels. Driving hasn’t become any cheaper in recent years, with petrol prices rising and the costs of car ownership higher than ever before. However, rail fares have risen so steeply that driving may actually be the more economical choice. For those who cannot drive or do not have access to a car, the cost of a train ticket is becoming increasingly prohibitive.

It also restricts those looking for jobs, or who work away from the local area. Scarborough was recently identified as the ‘low pay capital’ of the UK, with a large number of local jobs paying well under the national living wage. For those who want higher paying work or are seeking work in specialist fields, there is often a need to travel to nearby cities like York, Hull and Leeds. Some may even commute further afield, for example travelling to London or Glasgow. However, the cost of travelling to and from these places each day can often amount to several hundred pounds per week, which limits the amount a person can earn.

What do you think? Join in the discussion here https://www.kialo.com/nationalising-the-railways-will-be-good-for-scarborough-and-whitby-12305